Stephen Kenny’s days as Ireland manager seem to be numbered after a dismal World Cup qualifying campaign that saw his side finish third in Group B behind the Netherlands and Norway. Kenny, who took over from Mick McCarthy in 2020, has only won four of his 19 games in charge, scoring just 12 goals and conceding 25.
The FAI has confirmed that Kenny will see out his contract until the end of the year, but a review of his performance will be conducted by the head of football Marc Canham, who will present his findings to the board. The board will then decide whether to extend Kenny’s contract or look for a new manager.
While Kenny still has some supporters who believe in his vision of playing attractive and progressive football, there are also many critics who question his tactics, team selection and results. Some of the names that have been linked with the Ireland job in case Kenny is sacked are:
- Roy Keane: The former Manchester United and Ireland captain is the favourite to take over from Kenny, according to Paddy Power. Keane has a proven track record of winning trophies in England and Scotland, as well as managing in the Premier League and the Championship. He is also a former Ireland international who played 67 times for his country and led them to the 2002 World Cup, before leaving the squad in a controversial dispute with manager Mick McCarthy. Keane was also the assistant manager of Ireland from 2013 to 2018, under Martin O’Neill. He could bring some much-needed experience, passion and leadership to the Ireland team. [7/4]
- Sam Allardyce: The former England manager is a controversial choice, but one that cannot be ruled out. Allardyce has a reputation for saving teams from relegation, having done so with Bolton, Blackburn, Sunderland and Crystal Palace. He also has a 100% record as England manager, having won his only game in charge against Slovakia in 2016. However, he resigned after being caught in a newspaper sting. Allardyce could offer some defensive solidity and organisation to the Ireland team, as well as a no-nonsense approach. [11/1]
- Lee Carsley: The former Everton and Ireland midfielder is another strong contender for the job, having impressed as the England Under-21 manager. Carsley led the young Lions to their first European Championship title since 1984, beating Spain in the final. He has also worked as an assistant manager at Manchester City and Birmingham City. Carsley could be the ideal candidate to nurture the emerging talent in the Ireland squad and implement a modern and exciting style of play. [4/1]
- Steve Bruce: The veteran manager has been out of work since leaving West Brom in January 2023, following a brief spell at the Hawthorns. Bruce has managed several clubs in the Premier League, including Newcastle, Sunderland and Aston Villa. He has also played for Manchester United and captained them to three league titles. Bruce could bring some stability and pragmatism to the Ireland team, as well as a wealth of experience and knowledge. [9/2]
- Chris Hughton: The former Ireland defender and assistant manager is another familiar name that has been mentioned as a possible successor to Kenny. Hughton has managed several clubs in England, including Newcastle, Norwich, Brighton and Nottingham Forest. He has also won promotion to the Premier League twice, with Newcastle and Brighton. Hughton is currently the head coach of Ghana, having taken over in February 2023. He has guided them to the African Cup of Nations, which will take place in February 2024. Hughton could bring some defensive discipline and tactical awareness to the Ireland team, as well as a connection with the Irish fans. [20/1]
However, despite the speculation and rumours, there are also reports that Kenny may end up keeping his job at the end of the year. The FAI may decide to give him another chance to prove himself, especially with the Euro 2028 on the horizon, which Ireland will co-host with Scotland and Wales. Kenny may also benefit from the support of some of the senior players, who have backed him publicly and privately. Kenny may also point to the positive signs of improvement and potential in some of the games, such as the 1-1 draw with the Netherlands in Dublin and the 3-1 win over Norway in Oslo.
Whatever the outcome, the next few weeks will be crucial for Kenny and the future of Irish football. The fans will be hoping for some positive results and performances, as well as some clarity and direction from the FAI. The Ireland manager’s job is one of the most prestigious and challenging in world football, and it deserves the best possible candidate. Who will that be? Only time will tell.